[Kolab-devel] [issue1928] Unencrypted email send, when s/mime encryption activated, OpenPGP key selected, always encrypt-to-self off

[Bernhard Reiter]

New submission from Bernhard Reiter <bernhard at intevation.de>:

There is a chance to send unencrypted emails,      
though you had encryption activated (this makes it critical).      
      
Reproducable with Proko2 2.1.7 and      
Kontact: 1.0 (proko2 branch after 2.1.10), debug=yes, Revision 704237.     
Debian Sarge (ppc) with KDE: 3.3.2 Qt: 3.3.4     
     
Ludwig: Can you test this on enterprise35 as well please?     
     
To reproduce:     
* Make sure that the setting "always encrypt to myself" in the    
  Kontact settings -> Mail -> security -> create messages (or so) is     
  deactivated. Also it is practical to have the option to show keys   
  before encryption activated.    
* Create a new email. Make sure encryption and S/MIME is selected.    
* It is easiest to address it to yourself, though the recipient does not   
matter.    
* Now press send and you get the dialog which shows to which keys it will   
  be encrypted. Use "change" on the encryption key and select an _OpenPGP_   
  key and okay both.   
* Receive the email and see that it is in cleartext, in both in the email   
  send and the send-folder. (It should be cleartext in the send-folder when   
  the corresponding option is selected.)   
   
Expected behaviour:   
* the unencrypted email should not go out unnoticed when I did select encrypt. 
 
Observation: There is not gnupgwatch log after okaying the key, thus the defect 
will most likely be within KMail.

----------
assignedto: till
messages: 11727
nosy: bernhard, ludwig, till, vkrause
priority: critical
status: unread
title: Unencrypted email send, when s/mime encryption activated, OpenPGP key selected, always encrypt-to-self off
topic: kde client, kkc
________________________________________________
Kolab issue tracker <kolab-issues at intevation.de>
<https://intevation.de/roundup/kolab/issue1928>
________________________________________________