[Kolab-devel] Kolab 2.1 Distribution list

gelpi@corona.it corona at gelpi.it
Fri Jan 20 15:47:00 CET 2006 

Tobias Brunner wrote:
> Quoting "gelpi at corona.it" <corona at gelpi.it>:
> 
>> Tobias Brunner wrote:
>>
>>> Quoting "gelpi at corona.it" <corona at gelpi.it>:
>>>
>>>
>>>> Tobias Brunner wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> Hi everybody
>>>>>
>>>>> I'm having the same problems as Andrea.
>>>>> I installed the 2.1 development december 15 snapshot.
>>>>> The distribution lists are not working.
>>>>>
>>>>> As discussed, I changed the ownership definition in the file
>>>>> ldapdistlist.cf.template to OWNERSHIP=kolab-n:kolab-r. After running
>>>>> kolabconf, the permission on the file was changed correctly.
>>>>> I also deleted the entry "root: /dev/null" in
>>>>> /kolab/etc/postfix/aliases so the mails to root doesn't end in the
>>>>> nirvana.
>>>>>
>>>>> Now when I send a mail to for example postmaster at tobru.ch, it looks
>>>>> like this in the postfix.log:
>>>>>
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:50 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[13204]: connect from
>>>>> mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11]
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:50 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[13204]: D544F20717:
>>>>> client=mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11]
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:50 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[13207]: D544F20717:
>>>>> message-id=<OF64A7BC49.5DDA4E1B-ONC12570FB.00491C2E-C12570FB.00492093 at SUISA.CH> 
>>>>>
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:50 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[8644]: D544F20717:
>>>>> from=<Tobias.Brunner at suisa.ch>, size=1059, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:50 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[13204]: disconnect from
>>>>> mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11]
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[13210]: connect from
>>>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[13210]: 13E8420719:
>>>>> client=localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[13211]: 13E8420719:
>>>>> message-id=<OF64A7BC49.5DDA4E1B-ONC12570FB.00491C2E-C12570FB.00492093 at SUISA.CH> 
>>>>>
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[8644]: 13E8420719:
>>>>> from=<tobias.brunner at suisa.ch>, size=1237, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[13210]: disconnect from
>>>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/pipe[13208]: D544F20717:
>>>>> to=<postmaster at tobru.ch>, relay=kolabfilter, delay=1, status=sent
>>>>> (iffigenia.tobru.ch)
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[8644]: D544F20717: 
>>>>> removed
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[13215]: connect from
>>>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[13215]: BD7D62071B:
>>>>> client=localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[13211]: BD7D62071B:
>>>>> message-id=<OF64A7BC49.5DDA4E1B-ONC12570FB.00491C2E-C12570FB.00492093 at SUISA.CH> 
>>>>>
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[8644]: BD7D62071B:
>>>>> from=<tobias.brunner at suisa.ch>, size=1833, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[13215]: disconnect from
>>>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtp[13212]: 13E8420719:
>>>>> to=<postmaster at tobru.ch>, relay=127.0.0.1[127.0.0.1], delay=0,
>>>>> status=sent (250 2.6.0 Ok, id=12726-01, from MTA([127.0.0.1]:10026):
>>>>> 250 Ok: queued as BD7D62071B)
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[8644]: 13E8420719: 
>>>>> removed
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/pipe[13217]: BD7D62071B:
>>>>> to=<root at tobru.ch>, orig_to=<postmaster at tobru.ch>,
>>>>> relay=kolabmailboxfilter, delay=0, status=bounced (service
>>>>> unavailable. Command output: Failed to set recipient: Invalid response
>>>>> code received from server, code 550 )
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:51 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[13207]: EDD232071C:
>>>>> message-id=<20060119130851.EDD232071C at iffigenia.tobru.ch>
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:52 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[8644]: EDD232071C:
>>>>> from=<>, size=3758, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:52 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[8644]: BD7D62071B: 
>>>>> removed
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:52 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtp[13221]: EDD232071C:
>>>>> to=<tobias.brunner at suisa.ch>, relay=mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11],
>>>>> delay=1, status=sent (250 2.0.0 Message received OK)
>>>>> Jan 19 14:08:52 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[8644]: EDD232071C: 
>>>>> removed
>>>>>
>>>>> Why is postfix trying to send this mail to root at tobru.ch? The
>>>>> distribtion List points to tobruadmin at tobru.ch and this account exists
>>>>> in Kolab and is able to receive mails directly sent to this mail
>>>>> address.
>>>>> Ok, it sends this mail to root at tobru.ch because this is defined in the
>>>>> aliases file. But why is that defined? Do I have to add a user
>>>>> "root at tobru.ch"? I tried to add an alias to tobruadmin at tobru.ch but is
>>>>> isn't working either.
>>>>> Mails to distribution list addresses which are not defined in the
>>>>> aliases file don't work either (f.e. virusalert). The output to the
>>>>> postfix.log looks similar to this above (code 550).
>>>>>
>>>>> Please help me to get the distribution lists working!
>>>>>
>>>>> Thanks a lot
>>>>> Tobias
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Try this:
>>>>
>>>> Add virtual_alias_maps that points to virtual_maps.
>>>>
>>>> Run kolabconf and verify all is working.
>>>>
>>>> After that remove virtual_alias_maps and verify aliases are still 
>>>> working.
>>>>
>>>> When I run into that problem I remember that postconf doesn't show
>>>> virtual_alias_maps till I add it manually.
>>>>
>>>> I think this is a postfix problem. If you search your logs Postifix 
>>>> says
>>>> the lookup table are not owned by root.
>>>>
>>>> Let me know.
>>>>
>>>> Andrea Gelpi
>>>>
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> Kolab-devel mailing list
>>>> Kolab-devel at kolab.org
>>>> https://kolab.org/mailman/listinfo/kolab-devel
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Hi
>>>
>>> Hmm, this does not help.
>>> If I look at the logfiles, it is still the same as before =(
>>>
>>> Mail to postmaster at tobru.ch:
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17560]: connect from
>>> mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11]
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17560]: 6A14D18384:
>>> client=mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11]
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[17564]: 6A14D18384:
>>> message-id=<OFABE72608.2CB80228-ONC12570FC.0029DA17-C12570FC.0029DE9B at SUISA.CH> 
>>>
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 6A14D18384:
>>> from=<Tobias.Brunner at suisa.ch>, size=1072, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17560]: disconnect from
>>> mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11]
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17567]: connect from
>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17567]: 9203920750:
>>> client=localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[17568]: 9203920750:
>>> message-id=<OFABE72608.2CB80228-ONC12570FC.0029DA17-C12570FC.0029DE9B at SUISA.CH> 
>>>
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 9203920750:
>>> from=<tobias.brunner at suisa.ch>, size=1250, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17567]: disconnect from
>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/pipe[17565]: 6A14D18384:
>>> to=<postmaster at tobru.ch>, relay=kolabfilter, delay=0, status=sent
>>> (iffigenia.tobru.ch)
>>> Jan 20 08:35:27 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 6A14D18384: 
>>> removed
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17572]: connect from
>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17572]: 0366818384:
>>> client=localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[17568]: 0366818384:
>>> message-id=<OFABE72608.2CB80228-ONC12570FC.0029DA17-C12570FC.0029DE9B at SUISA.CH> 
>>>
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 0366818384:
>>> from=<tobias.brunner at suisa.ch>, size=1848, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17572]: disconnect from
>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtp[17569]: 9203920750:
>>> to=<postmaster at tobru.ch>, relay=127.0.0.1[127.0.0.1], delay=1,
>>> status=sent (250 2.6.0 Ok, id=14714-05, from MTA([127.0.0.1]:10026):
>>> 250 Ok: queued as 0366818384)
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 9203920750: 
>>> removed
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/pipe[17574]: 0366818384:
>>> to=<root at tobru.ch>, orig_to=<postmaster at tobru.ch>,
>>> relay=kolabmailboxfilter, delay=0, status=bounced (service
>>> unavailable. Command output: Failed to set recipient: Invalid response
>>> code received from server, code 550 )
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[17564]: 2C99220750:
>>> message-id=<20060120073528.2C99220750 at iffigenia.tobru.ch>
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 2C99220750:
>>> from=<>, size=3773, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 0366818384: 
>>> removed
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtp[17579]: 2C99220750:
>>> to=<tobias.brunner at suisa.ch>, relay=mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11],
>>> delay=0, status=sent (250 2.0.0 Message received OK)
>>> Jan 20 08:35:28 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 2C99220750: 
>>> removed
>>>
>>> Mail to gugus at tobru.ch (defined distribution list):
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17560]: connect from
>>> mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11]
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17560]: 7124420750:
>>> client=mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11]
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[17564]: 7124420750:
>>> message-id=<OF073EA3E5.97353458-ONC12570FC.0029FD40-C12570FC.0029FE8D at SUISA.CH> 
>>>
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 7124420750:
>>> from=<Tobias.Brunner at suisa.ch>, size=1039, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17560]: disconnect from
>>> mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11]
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17567]: connect from
>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17567]: 9CC8220763:
>>> client=localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[17568]: 9CC8220763:
>>> message-id=<OF073EA3E5.97353458-ONC12570FC.0029FD40-C12570FC.0029FE8D at SUISA.CH> 
>>>
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 9CC8220763:
>>> from=<tobias.brunner at suisa.ch>, size=1212, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17567]: disconnect from
>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/pipe[17565]: 7124420750:
>>> to=<gugus at tobru.ch>, relay=kolabfilter, delay=0, status=sent
>>> (iffigenia.tobru.ch)
>>> Jan 20 08:36:35 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 7124420750: 
>>> removed
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17572]: connect from
>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17572]: 1661920750:
>>> client=localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[17568]: 1661920750:
>>> message-id=<OF073EA3E5.97353458-ONC12570FC.0029FD40-C12570FC.0029FE8D at SUISA.CH> 
>>>
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 1661920750:
>>> from=<tobias.brunner at suisa.ch>, size=1800, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtp[17569]: 9CC8220763:
>>> to=<gugus at tobru.ch>, relay=127.0.0.1[127.0.0.1], delay=1, status=sent
>>> (250 2.6.0 Ok, id=14715-05, from MTA([127.0.0.1]:10026): 250 Ok:
>>> queued as 1661920750)
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 9CC8220763: 
>>> removed
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtpd[17572]: disconnect from
>>> localhost[127.0.0.1]
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/pipe[17574]: 1661920750:
>>> to=<gugus at tobru.ch>, relay=kolabmailboxfilter, delay=0, status=bounced
>>> (service unavailable. Command output: Failed to set recipient: Invalid
>>> response code received from server, code 550 )
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/cleanup[17564]: 43B5820763:
>>> message-id=<20060120073636.43B5820763 at iffigenia.tobru.ch>
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 43B5820763:
>>> from=<>, size=3635, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 1661920750: 
>>> removed
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/smtp[17579]: 43B5820763:
>>> to=<tobias.brunner at suisa.ch>, relay=mail.suisa.ch[193.8.197.11],
>>> delay=0, status=sent (250 2.0.0 Message received OK)
>>> Jan 20 08:36:36 iffigenia <info> postfix/qmgr[17493]: 43B5820763: 
>>> removed
>>>
>>> Regards
>>> Tobias
>>>
>>
>> Hi,
>>
>> hmm ... does postconf give you the same as me?
>>
>> postconf | grep virtual_alias_maps
>>
>> proxy_read_maps = $local_recipient_maps $mydestination
>> $virtual_alias_maps $virtual_alias_domains $virtual_mailbox_maps
>> $virtual_mailbox_domains $relay_recipient_maps $relay_domains
>> $canonical_maps $sender_canonical_maps $recipient_canonical_maps
>> $relocated_maps $transport_maps $mynetworks
>> virtual_alias_domains = $virtual_alias_maps
>> virtual_alias_maps = $virtual_maps
>>
>>
>> To debug the problem I modified master.cf adding to the first istance of
>> smtpd, -v three times.
>>
>> After that in postfix log I was be able to discover which lookup tables
>> are search.
>>
>> I found that virtual_alias_table at the beginning was blank!
>>
>> Andrea Gelpi
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Kolab-devel mailing list
>> Kolab-devel at kolab.org
>> https://kolab.org/mailman/listinfo/kolab-devel
>>
>>
>>
> 
> Yes, postconf gives me exactly the same!
> 
> I added the 3 -v's to the first istance of smtpd in master.cf and   
> looked at the logfile,
> but it is very, very huge and I have some  problem to find the right 
> section.
> But what I found is the same as you wrote in an earlier post, the   
> question marks at this
> line:
> dict_lookup: virtual_maps = hash:/kolab/etc/postfix/virtual,
> ?ldap:/kolab/etc/postfix/ldapdistlist.cf,   
> ?ldap:/kolab/etc/postfix/ldapvirtual.cf
> I checked the permissions on this files, but they seem to be ok:
> -rw-r-----   1 kolab-n kolab-r   879 Jan 20 14:03 ldapdistlist.cf
> -rw-r-----   1 kolab-n kolab-r   774 Jan 20 14:03 ldapvirtual.cf
> -rw-r-----   1 root    root      559 Jan 20 14:03 virtual
> 
> I attached the logfile.
> 
> Regards
> Tobias

Are you sure that at 13:40 when postfix was reloaded the permissions are 
coorect?
The question mark you see seems to indicate a permission problem. I 
solved the case when I changed them.

Another thing. Have you seen the post by Pietrosanti saing that in 
ldapdistlist.cf the keyword domain, must be removed?

That is the other thing I've done.

Andrea Gelpi

More information about the devel mailing list